What's the call?

[Totes Magoats]

Scenario is irrelevant.  Watch the pistol when the rifle is discarded.

 

WTC?

 

[Cayuse Jack]

Broke the 170, SDQ

 

Hard to see at the start, what about the finger on the trigger while racking the slide?

[Old Man Graybeard]

I couldn't tell if the finger was in the trigger guard at the start or along side the frame...as at the second position. I shoot traditional...and sometimes get yelled at for finger...but what I am doing is hitting the mag release

[Eyesa]

I couldn't discern the trigger finger. But agree with SDQ for breaking the 170 with the pistol. What was the actual call?

[Flying W Ramrod]

4 hours ago, Cayuse Jack said:

Broke the 170, SDQ

 

Hard to see at the start, what about the finger on the trigger while racking the slide?

There is no rule about keeping the trigger finger off the trigger when initially charging the pistol. The only finger rule is; when changing mags, moving, correcting malfunctions.

WBAS SHB Pg 14 "When handling the 1911, the shooter’s trigger finger must be outside the trigger guard when moving, reloading, or clearing a malfunction after the pistol is first charged."

No call on the trigger finger.

SDQ on the 1911 after the rifle smacked it, though.

[Totes Magoats]

MSV was called. There was discussion on how the pistol got into the position.  Should be SDQ. 
 

As for the finger at the start. I had it pinned to the top front side of the trigger guard where it meets the frame. 
 

Totes

[Burt the Undertaker]

The pistol flipped over (didn't rotate) and it doesn't look like it's breaking the 170°. It's close but I personally don't think it is....

[Garrison Joe]

You have to be on the firing line to determine "breaking the 170."  Looking at a video is NOT the way to judge it.  I'll trust the eye witnesses who were right there.  good luck, GJ

[El Chapo]

14 hours ago, Totes Magoats said:

MSV was called. There was discussion on how the pistol got into the position.  Should be SDQ. 

 

What was the basis for that call?